![]() |
| Gary Larson |
This is going to be a post where I'm screaming into the void.
For obvious reasons there is a renewed interest in heritage and ancestry and geneological descendants. Here we go again.
I'm reading blogs and SM posts where people are doing their geneological trees (unless you go into archival records of births almost impossible) and DNA ancestry.
The latter is probably one of the best scams I've ever seen.
1. This is not how DNA or the genome works
2. There is no test at present that can test your ancestry accurately. I DONT CARE WHAT THE INTERNET SAYS.
Seniors are the most gullible target group
3. Your genetic information is your property
DNA based Anc.
This is data fed into a computer database and your paying for a printout. If you have anything African in your printout (and you're white); congratulations you got duped.
Most Americans have European heritage. If youre white based on the law of probability there'll be a high percentage of a European mix. Mostly western because...eastern Europeans didn't track it and there is not much of a data base in North/west Africa, especially none that could differentiate countries there.
So. Where are all those genome differences coming from if there is no data set to compare it to and differentiate from?
Well. Your geographic location is one data set. Haven't seen the forms you fill out. Next up is that it's being compared to other people who are sending it in, probably not your ancestors.
POCs can be African, Caribbean or other places. Also not being considered because there is NO data. (I'm picturing some poor bloke named John Lamar the fifth sitting in an office: Hey John could we take a swab again to throw it into the mix again as evidence)
Instead of a pyramid scheme you're probably getting friends and family involved because hey you're from France (dating as far back as Gaul?) or Prussia or Germania or I'm tired of this.
23a.me was valued at 6billion in 2021, probably made 5.9, went bankrupt, selling your genetic info in the process. There's a class action lawsuit at the moment:
https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2024/nov/30/why-i-regret-using-23andme-i-gave-up-my-dna-just-to-find-out-im-british
I'm angry because I'm tall, blonde and blue-eyed and for the last decade I have to listen to strangers' ancestral history (who approach me in RL) when I wasn't asking and it's getting more frequent. (See previous posts). And because this is harming humans and animals alike.
Covid went Bat to human to human. Suddenly pangolin DNA was in the test. They are critically endangered already.
If this BS continues then you may have to explain that ancestral derpy shepherd in your genome to your family one day.
Here are some ethical implications dating back to 2009:
https://jlhochschild.scholars.harvard.edu/publications/politics-genomics-research-implications-dna-racial-identity-and-race-based
And for your DNA as your property (and another lawsuit)
The immortal life of Henrietta Lacks by Rebecca Skloot is a very good book
Submitting your DNA may have the opposite effect of what you intend.





